Has your favourite cookie been discontinued?

Lady Scouts

Ever puzzled why the Lady Scout cookies you order have a distinct title typically? Or why some flavors stick round whereas others come and go? There is a purpose for all of it.

The Lady Scouts have been promoting cookies since 1917, and thru licensed bakers because the Thirties. By means of these years, the flavors, names and availability of cookies have gone via many adjustments because the Lady Scouts introduce new cookies and retire others.

I am going to share some fascinating info about Lady Scout cookies that you could be not find out about. All the data comes from assets offered by the Lady Scouts. For extra, this is how I ranked all 12 Lady Scout cookies and the right way to DoorDash Lady Scout cookies to your home.

51 Lady Scout cookie flavors have been discontinued

Over time, dozens of Lady Scout cookies have come and gone. A preferred cookie, Thanks-A-Lot, was just lately discontinued in 2021 after being within the lineup for 15 years. It was changed by a brand new cookie, Toast-Yay, a French toast-flavored cookie dipped in icing.

It is as much as every of the greater than 100 native Lady Scout councils to determine which cookies will probably be baked of their space for the 12 months and which of them will probably be shelved indefinitely. Solely three flavors are necessary for the bakers to make for every council (see beneath). 

Solely 3 cookies are necessary and can’t be discontinued

In 1951, there have been three Lady Scout cookie flavors being offered: Chocolate Mints, Peanut Butter Sandwich and Shortbreads. These cookies at the moment are generally often known as Skinny Mints, Do-si-dos and Trefoils. These three flavors are additionally the one cookies that may by no means be eradicated from the lineup. Sure, which means the beloved Samoas and Tagalongs will be nixed if the Lady Scout group chooses to eliminate them (although I do not assume that’ll occur anytime quickly).

The cookies are made in 2 totally different bakeries

Lady Scout cookies at the moment are made in simply two bakeries: Little Brownie Bakers and ABC Bakers. However it hasn’t at all times been that approach. In 1948, there have been 29 bakers licensed to bake Lady Scout cookies. By the Nineteen Sixties, that quantity had dropped to 14, after which to 4 bakers in 1978. It wasn’t till the Nineties that the Lady Scouts streamlined to simply two bakers.

And sure, you possibly can usually inform once you get a cookie that is not out of your typical Lady Scout area (see beneath).


Your cookies could style totally different for those who get them from a distinct baker than typical.

Lady Scouts

The recipes are totally different between the two bakeries

Resulting from a licensing subject, the 2 bakers do not appear to make use of the identical recipe in each case, and that is why a number of the cookies have two totally different names. As an example, Samoas come from Little Brownie Bakers, whereas Caramel deLites come from ABC Bakers. The 2 cookies look the identical, however for those who examine the vitamin labels and examine how they style, they’re fairly totally different.

Throughout my Lady Scout cookie style check, I obtained Peanut Butter Patties as an alternative of Tagalongs and seen an enormous distinction within the taste and texture. Tagalongs have extra peanut butter whereas the Peanut Butter Patties simply have one layer. The Skinny Mints from ABC Bakers are additionally thinner and crunchier than those Little Brownie Bakers produces.

A number of the different in style cookies with totally different names are Do-Si-Dos/Peanut Butter Sandwich and Trefoils/Shortbread.

How are you aware which cookie you may get? Test to see which area you fall into.

There’s an argument between Skinny Mints and Samoas followers

Ah, the divisive cookie debate between Skinny Mints and Samoas. Throughout my style check to find out which Lady Scout cookies had been the perfect, I despatched a survey to my colleagues to get their ideas. The bulk voted for Samoas cookies (54.5%), whereas 27.3% voted for Skinny Mints. 

Even Justin Timberlake riled up some followers with the Samoas versus Skinny Mints cookie debate in a video he posted on Twitter in 2020, noting it was a “contentious topic.” He isn’t flawed.

Inform a Skinny Mints lover that your favourite Lady Scout cookie is a Samoa and see what their response is. 

Lady Scouts used to bake their very own cookies at residence

When Lady Scout cookies first turned a factor, the Lady Scouts would bake them at residence. Nonetheless, at the moment, there was just one recipe for a sugar cookie. They had been offered for 25 to 35 cents per dozen — now they’re between $5 and $6 per field.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.